A reflection on Luke 5:17–26 for Monday of the 2nd Week of Advent.
“Which is easier, to say, ‘Your sins are forgiven you,’ or to say, ‘Stand up and walk’?” I keep noticing the word “say”. I could say either sentence. If I told the paralysed man to walk, though, everyone would soon discover whether my words had any authority.
The scribes and Pharisees are asking a serious question. Forgiveness belongs to God. How can this man claim to exercise it? Luke lets us hear their reasoning, and Jesus answers by giving them something to watch.
A few moments earlier, that bed had been lowered through the roof with him lying on it. Now at the word of Jesus he lifts it himself. Luke is quite specific about the reversal. The people who helped lower him can watch him pick up the bed himself. . Nobody needs an explanation of what has happened to his legs. What has happened concerning his sins is harder to establish, even as he walks past them.
Jesus joins the two in his answer. He heals so that they may know the Son of Man has authority on earth to forgive sins. They have heard him claim authority to forgive sins. Now the man he addressed is standing in front of them. Watching someone walk does not, by itself, tell you everything about the person who healed him.
I wonder how the question sounded after the man had gone. The crowd praises God, but I would not expect the scribes’ theological difficulty to disappear quite as quickly. They have witnessed a healing. They have also heard Jesus claim an authority they understand to belong to God. That is rather a lot to take home.
Prayer
Lord Jesus, I cannot see forgiveness as I can see someone rise and walk. Help me trust your authority to heal and forgive. Amen.

